Who Has the Best Pizza in Rochester? Here’s What Locals Told Us
Pizza is serious business in Rochester, and everyone has a go-to spot. We ran an open survey for the month of April asking locals to vote for their favorite pizzeria—and the responses gave us a clear look at where people are actually ordering from and recommending to friends.
There was one clear winner, but plenty of others received strong support and loyal praise. Below, you’ll find the top vote-getter, followed by the rest of the Top 10 pizza places in Rochester according to our community. Whether you like it thin and crispy, wood-fired, or piled high with toppings, this list has something for every kind of pizza lover.
Best Pizza in Rochester, NY – As Voted by the Community
🥇 #1 – Pizza Wizard
Crispy crust, clever combos, and a strong following helped Pizza Wizard take the crown.
🥈 #2 – Peels on Wheels
A mobile powerhouse that’s earned its place with bold flavor and a loyal base.
🥉 #3 – Pontillo’s
A hometown classic that still draws fans with its familiar taste and consistency. Best rated delivery in our survey.
Top 10 Best Pizza – Rochester NY
- Pizza Wizard – (23.2%)
- Peels on Wheels – (15.2%)
- Pontillo’s – (10.4%)
- Carbone’s – (9.6%)
- The Pizza Stop – (6.4%)
- TK’s – (5.6%)
- Guida’s Pizzeria – (4.8%)
- Joe’s Brooklyn – (4.0%)
- TIE – (2.4% each)
- TIE – (1.6% each)